Are You Certain?
By Jessica Lake
I’ve made decisions I knew were right. Absolutely. Beyond question. Unfortunately, SDAM kept the verdict and misplaced the trial. Now I’m left defending conclusions whose witnesses have all gone home. Was that moral conviction? Something I learned at six? Or simply the last explanation standing? Certainty is a wonderful thing. I’m beginning to think it should come with a receipt.
Below are a pair of moments from my younger days that puzzled me for decades.
Only after retirement did I realize they revealed something important about the way my mind works.
I am not recounting these moments as recollections in the usual manner. Having SDAM, I cannot relive those moments emotionally or narratively.
What follows is semantic reconstruction. The facts provide the evidence that I string together; the explanation reflects my current inference of the architecture.
The first episode occurred in my senior year of college. There was a girl I adored for her brilliance at computer language design. She mentored me, helping me progress from a C to an A.
One night she appeared at my dorm room soaked to the skin from the rain, sobbing, and wearing almost nothing. Once inside, she removed her wet clothes. I helped her dry off with towels, found dry clothing for her, and helped her get dressed. I know I hugged her to warm her up.
At the time, the situation felt strangely straightforward to me. She was upset. She needed help. So I helped her.
What is remarkable is that I had never seen a naked woman before. I would not have sex for another seven or eight years. Yet the thought barely entered my mind.
The reason, I think, is simple. She had told me she was married.
The moment that fact entered the equation, the entire situation cemented itself. She became categorically off-limits.
Not a temptation I had to resist. Not morally difficult. Simply unavailable. The possibility itself seemed to collapse.
I helped her dry off, get dressed, and get warm. That was the problem before me.
What stayed with me afterward was not frustration or longing. It was incoherence. I could never fully fathom why she had come to me in the first place.
Only twenty years later did I finally realize that my interpretation may not have been hers. Looking back, I wonder whether she had hoped for intimacy, perhaps including sexual closeness. I do not know.
At the time, however, I did not consciously suppress anything. The possibility of sex never fully formed.
The second event happened years later, after college.
A woman with whom I practiced martial arts invited me to her home. While we were talking casually, she mentioned that her husband was away.
Then, suddenly, I experienced something I have only felt a few times in my life. A completely primal desire.
Not abstract admiration. Not intellectual attraction. Not emotional attachment. Just physical imperative.
I want to have sex with this woman. Now.
The experience startled me. There was no analysis first. No abstraction. Just desire.
Then, immediately, the structure returned.
She is married. Her husband is my friend. This is wrong.
And the situation resolved itself.
What fascinates me now is not the sexuality. It is the certainty.
I did not experience a prolonged negotiation. I experienced an answer.
At first, I interpreted that as moral certainty. Decades later, I began to suspect something else was happening.
Within my current model, the situation had entered a semantic architecture already containing declarations about obligation, loyalty, and what was admissible.
The answer did not need to be consciously debated. Enough constraints were already present. The solution converged.
She is married. Her husband is my friend. This is wrong. Done.
Desire had occurred. But once the relevant constraints were applied, acting upon it no longer remained admissible. That distinction matters.
For years, I described some of my persistent prohibitions as trauma rules. I no longer assume that explanation.
What I can report are the declarations that remained:
Don’t depend. Don’t ask. Don’t receive. Don’t risk disapproval. Don’t expose anything another person can use against you.
Become useful. Become harmless. Adapt.
I cannot revisit their formation. I cannot put the child on the stand and ask when each appeared, what she understood, or how a particular conclusion came to persist.
I know there was childhood duress. I know these declarations became part of how I operated.
My current model describes a process:
Destabilize. Obsess. Perfect. Adapt. Stabilize.
Experience supplies constraints. The architecture resolves the problem under those constraints. What works can become part of the configuration brought to the next problem.
That is an architectural explanation, not a recovered history of each declaration.
The child was not necessarily planning a seventy-year life. The problem could have been Tuesday.
Once a conclusion becomes part of semantic knowledge, it need not arrive labeled:
Generated in Childhood — Review Before Use
It can simply describe the world.
That is the part I find unsettling. A conclusion does not necessarily feel like a conclusion from inside the architecture. It can feel like reality.
This recognition did not remain confined to moral or sexual situations. The same pattern appears in some of the most consequential resolutions of my life.
I have been married twice. I divorced both spouses with absolute certainty.
In both cases, the decision was immediate, final, and never revisited. I did not attempt repair. I did not examine motive. I did not spend months weighing alternatives.
At the time, this felt like resolve. Looking back, the experience is strikingly familiar.
Something happened. The configuration changed. And suddenly the answer was obvious.
For years, I described this as:
Pattern detected. Rule fired. State overwritten.
I now think that was too procedural. There need not have been a little instruction somewhere saying:
Divorce Now
The situation changed the active constraints.
Within my current model, possibilities that had previously remained admissible no longer survived them. By the time the result reached conscious awareness, much of the problem may already have been resolved.
That creates a peculiar relationship with agency.
A resolution occurred. I acted upon it. But neither the certainty nor the action establishes that an agent chose among personally preferred alternatives.
Nor do I need to move that agent backward into childhood. The architecture could have generated an earlier solution just as it generated the later one.
What matters is that certainty is not evidence that a decision has been freshly examined. Sometimes certainty may mean that the architecture has already resolved the problem.
That explains something else that puzzled me for most of my life.
In my experience, rules, moral convictions, worldview, goals, and identity all inhabit the same semantic world. They do not reliably arrive with provenance tags.
A childhood conclusion does not announce: I was generated when you were six.
A moral conviction does not announce: I am a philosophical position you adopted later.
Identity does not announce: I am a particular collection of persistent declarations.
They present themselves in the same language.
This is true. This is wrong. This is dangerous. This is who I am.
Without an episodic history through which I can revisit their formation, the origin of a conclusion may be unavailable.
The conclusion remains. The derivation is gone.
That may be why certainty has been so persuasive to me.
Semantic knowledge functions differently from autobiographical recollection. In my account, the particular experience may disappear while relationships, principles, and rules remain.
The particular is lost. The conclusion survives.
That does not mean old and new declarations cannot coexist. They can. My configuration is full of them.
Some agree. Some contradict. Some become relevant only under particular conditions. Some cease to matter for decades and suddenly become relevant again.
The architecture does not require a single rule to overwrite everything that came before it. It requires only enough relevant constraints for the present problem to become sufficiently defined.
This also changes how I think about the self that lived through childhood.
I do not need to posit an earlier, untouched person buried beneath a later one. My current model describes one evolving configuration.
My underlying nature was there. Experience supplied constraints. I adapted. The results became additional declarations within the same semantic system.
The circumstances changed. Many of the conclusions remained.
Without access to their formation, I cannot always distinguish what arose through experience from what belongs to my underlying nature.
There is a related distinction in how I experience relationships.
Because my life history is stored primarily as semantic knowledge, emotional continuity is not available to me through episodic reliving.
When a present situation changes, there is no great autobiographical procession automatically marching into consciousness:
Remember this Christmas. Remember that summer. Remember how she held you. Remember twenty years of accumulated tenderness.
I may know those things happened. But knowledge is not reliving. That difference matters.
The bond is real. The love is real. But much of its felt presence depends upon the situation that sustains it.
When the situation disappears, knowledge may remain while the emotional state does not.
Understanding this did not rewrite my architecture. It changed my understanding of what I had observed.
For most of my life, I interpreted many of these automatic certainties as evidence of defectiveness, weakness, coldness, or moral failure.
Later, I explained them through childhood trauma. Now I examine them as resolutions produced by an architecture operating under constraints.
Some outcomes were useful. Some were catastrophic. Frequently, they were both.
This realization emerged through writing.
I do not ordinarily discover something, put it aside, and later write an essay explaining the finished conclusion. Writing is part of my reasoning process.
Each sentence adds another declaration. Each contradiction supplies another constraint. Explanations survive or fail. The field narrows.
Sometimes an answer emerges. Sometimes another question does.
That process eventually led me to Constraint Convergence.
But Constraint Convergence is not the whole architecture. It operates upon a much larger semantic world: accumulated knowledge, fundamental principles, generators, constraints, and the compressed residue of a lifetime of experience.
That is the machinery I use to reconstruct a life I cannot revisit.
What remains are fragments without provenance. Conclusions whose derivations have disappeared. Structures without narrative.
This does not make me less human.
I have loved. I have grieved. I know I exist. I am sad that I will leave this world someday.
Those experiences do not require an autobiographical narrator to certify their existence. That is sufficient.
In that sense, my memories resemble archaeology rather than recollection.
A few fragments remain: a dorm room, rain, warm towels, a crying woman.
And a sentence:
“I’m married.”
The rest must be inferred. Not relived. Reconstructed.
And perhaps that is why I have learned to be suspicious whenever the answer arrives with absolute certainty.
Are you certain?
Yes. Of course I am.
Why?
Now that is a much more interesting question.
Are You Certain?
What does absolute certainty reveal—and what might it conceal? Through two encounters from her younger days, Jessica examines desire, moral conviction, and the constraints that shape her decisions. Reconstructing a life she cannot episodically revisit, she asks how conclusions whose origins are lost can come to feel like reality.