Free Will & Stuff
By Jessica Lake
I know all the reasons I should do something. I’ve examined the evidence. Reached a decision. Apparently, nobody told the rest of me. Now I have to make a persuasive case to a woman who already knows every argument I’m about to use. Me. Who is running this meeting? And why does deciding require so much lobbying? I went looking for free will and found myself rehearsing a sales pitch.
This is a small paper.
It does not propose some grand new architecture. Quite the opposite. I have been noticing how many perfectly ordinary things we do seem to fall rather neatly into the division of labor I have already described.
Planning. Persuasion. Temptation. Deliberation. Making up your mind.
They look like different things.
Perhaps they aren’t.
Free Will
I have been toying with free will.
“Off with her head!!” screamed the Red Queen.
Think about it.
Without free will, nobody would be responsible for their actions. We would all have Get Out of Jail Free cards.
And, as so often happens with me, what began as a fairly ordinary question has death-spiraled and landed somewhere unexpected.
Self-Persuasion
My best friend’s wife broadcasts that she is receptive to intercourse.
Nod and wink. Say no more.
The Devil says:
“Great sex with my best friend’s hot wife.”
The higher road is less obvious, but no less real.
The Angel says:
“I am unbowed by temptation.”
“A friend in need is a friend indeed.”
“I am someone a friend can depend on.”
“I meant what I said, and I said what I meant. An elephant’s faithful, one hundred percent!”
Virtue and a clear conscience are rewards too.
So we wrestle with Sin and Virtue.
Have great sex?
Take the high road?
The usual narrative says that I now have a conflict of interest. I must decide what I want more.
But wait—
I don’t think that is quite what happens.
What happens under the covers?
I think the conscious mind tries to persuade itself.
Other Persuasion
To understand this problem, we must consider another problem.
I have already suggested that the conscious mind is the seat of language.
Suppose I want something from you.
Big time.
I have narrowed down the possibilities to two arguments. Either might persuade you to give me what I want.
Which argument should I use?
I do not need to toss a coin. The mechanism already exists.
I need to cajole the target audience.
Say, perhaps, it is you.
My unsuspecting anonymous reader.
So I emulate you as my counterparty.
Frame an argument.
Pitch it against my model of you.
Did I close the deal?
No? Loop back to 1.
I am pitching and dismantling arguments. Calculating tactical and strategic consequences. I discover your weaknesses. I mature my argument over and over.
Eventually one argument appears more likely to succeed.
So I accept it.
Notice what I have selected.
Not the argument I find most attractive.
Not necessarily the argument I think is most righteous.
I select the argument that has the greatest chance of persuading the counterparty.
That is absolutely everyday persuasion.
Of course, my model of you may be wrong. I can construct a persuasive argument that fails miserably when presented to the actual person.
But that does not change the mechanism.
Volta!
Now flip the mechanism.
I am the counterparty.
I have two incompatible rewards.
Sex. 😍
Loyalty. 😭
Nothing else needs to change.
It is the same mechanism I use for persuading someone else.
Only now I model myself.
Does that sound suspiciously like wrestling with temptation?
Well, it kinda is.
But that does not demand an angel and devil on my shoulders.
There is one consciousness alternately testing competing arguments and outcomes against a simulation of itself.
That may be deliberation.
But it is not simply a matter of asking which reward is greatest.
The question is:
Which argument is more likely to persuade the adjudicator?
The argument for sex must survive everything else that is true about me and my model of the world.
My loyalty.
My pride in my virtue.
My friendship.
What if I’m found out?
Oh. The ignominy!
My future relationship with my friend.
My relationship with his wife.
Social consequences.
Regret.
My relationship with my wife!
And the kids?
And the ugly divorce?
Whatever prohibitions and principles currently exist within the counterparty.
Reality gets a vote.
So does conscience.
What if remaining loyal preserves my friendship but leaves me miserable?
Maybe the marriage was already on the rocks?
Perhaps my friend would understand?
Here is dialogue from a film:
Antoinette: “Have you ever been married?”
Billy: “Sure. A long time ago.”
Antoinette: “Did you love her?”
Billy: “With all my heart. Sometimes that just isn’t enough.”
Antoinette: “What happened?”
Billy: “I caught her in bed with my best friend.”
Antoinette: “What did you do to him?”
Billy: “I shot her.”
Antoinette: “What! What about him?”
Billy: “He was my best friend.”
There is no abstract answer called Loyalty or Sex sitting somewhere in semantic knowledge waiting to be retrieved.
There is this situation.
This is the self.
The rewards.
The constraints.
The predicted consequences.
Now solve it.
But there is another possibility.
Perhaps the process does not merely determine which argument the self will accept.
Perhaps repeated persuasion changes the self doing the accepting.
The Curving Path
This feels strangely familiar.
It is how I learn.
And perhaps it is also how I change.
Destabilize
I encounter something that does not fit.
An inconsistency. A temptation. An opportunity. A contradiction between what I want and what I believe.
The existing configuration cannot comfortably accommodate it.
Obsess
It feels like a spiral.
I repeatedly approach the same problem through different lenses. Each lens eliminates something, adds a constraint, or alters the proposition.
The problem remains open.
Perfect
The emerging resolution is repeatedly tested against the constraints.
I refine it.
I challenge it.
I search for contradictions.
Eventually I arrive at something from which I can no longer dislodge myself.
The resolution has become internally coherent.
Adapt
Now something different happens.
The configuration must accommodate the resolution.
What I previously believed, expected, permitted, or prohibited may have to change.
The self that began the deliberation need not be precisely the self that finishes it.
Stabilize
The new configuration becomes durable.
What once required deliberation may now seem obvious.
I call that “righteousness.”
Agency
This gives agency a peculiar character.
The conscious executive is not standing outside the organism negotiating directly with reality.
It is negotiating with the self as it currently exists.
Reality has supplied the circumstances.
Parallel subsystems have supplied rewards, prohibitions, expectations, fears, principles, opportunities, and candidate actions.
The conscious mind receives the resulting conundrum.
She attempts to locate a solution that her own configuration will accept.
And in doing so, she may change that configuration.
She does not command herself.
She persuades herself.
And perhaps that is why deep decisions can take so long.
When I say:
“I know all the reasons I should do it, but I still can’t convince myself it is right.”
I may be describing the mechanism almost literally.