Gender Bait & Switch

By Jessica Lake

At three, I apparently informed my mother that I was a changeling. SDAM has declined to elaborate. But I’ve spent seventy years insisting I was a girl, so perhaps the classification department deserves inspection. Boys were supposed to fight, compete, and stand up for themselves. I was gentle, yielding, and hopelessly helpful. Girl, then? Case closed. Evidence shredded. What happens when a childhood solution survives as unquestionable truth—and nobody remembers the question?

I think I finally have a plausible explanation for my brand of gender dysphoria. As you might expect, my thinking is a bit outside the box.

CAVEAT: This is my story. Mine. Not yours. Sorry.

BTW Not proof.

But plausible.

I have spent the last few years reverse-engineering my semantic mind. I now have a serviceable model that predicts an astonishing number of my behaviors.

Protracted Idleness broken by fits activity, sparse and weak recall, self perfection, rabid curiosity, sacrifice, time blindness, and problem resolution.

So suspend neurotypical psychology. Rather, let’s consider what the model predicts about my three-year-old self in 1955.

The Machine

The many favor episodic memory, which dotes on specificity. This happened to me— I felt this— I wanted that—

My autobiography is in the semantic knowledge parking lot. Knowledge favors repetition and invariance over idiosyncratic specificity. To me my past seems as interesting as old news.

Declarative memory to me is a reservoir. Many faculties rely upon it. My feelings is that SDAM starves the reliant faculties. As compensation the brain recruits semantic faculties. This diminishes many capacities. Saying its just different is like saying a software bug is a feature.

Autobiography flows into the semantic. Repetition and regularity mature knowing. It starts with observations of interest retained as facts. Maturation typifies examples facts into regularities. Mature regularities of wide scope become principals.

You indelibly retain the single occurrence of a notable return it

Facts they are notable you will also retain even if they happen once

You reference the knowledge above. A rules is dynamic. It couples a trigger pattern to default behaviors. Rules are critical for rapid response. A default behavior bypasses slower deliberation.

The examples fade, leaving the enduring truth. You cannot reconsider a truth. Case closed. The evidence is shredded. Ergo, to me, it is indelible truth.

Tolerance

Knowledge is like that.

Let’s say you observe that situation X bothers the hell out of you. Glitch. Once X is (T)rue, it cannot be more so. X • 10¹⁰⁰ equals X.

Along a timeline, left to right:

This yields the patience of a saint. You are very tolerant. Too tolerant. You don’t fix little things. Your job sucks 10¹⁰⁰ times, and you stay.

Countless

Let r be a day when a bully bullies you in fourth grade. Enough reps, and it matures into a regularity, R.

The adult you wonders, “How often was I bullied?” Knowing it is so doesn’t help. It could be between 10⁰ and 10¹⁰⁰.

Big Questions

How do I make life decisions? Easy. I enlist Constraint Convergence.

We all do it.

It’s a writing-class final.

You are exasperated.

What exactly is that word?

It is a little like pornography.

You’ll know it when you see it.

Who chose the right word?

Nobody. It emerged.

Great algorithm, right?

Nope.

Ask: What is the best job for Jessica?

There is an answer. After 10¹⁰⁰ repetitions of “No, that’s not it”:

“Dishwasher?”

Q: What’s wrong?

A: The problem is that Constraint Convergence is semantically objective.

Nope. Constraint Convergence can’t answer those questions.

Q: I’m stuck! Help?

A: Ask somebody.

Q: But it’s my life!

A: Nope. You don’t get a life.

Virtuous

I want A.

You want B.

Okay.

In semantic reasoning, you and I are equals. What I prefer holds no gravity.

Reality doesn’t give a fig what Jessica wants.

Boo-hoo.

Neither does Constraint Convergence.

This selflessness inspires a raft of divine side effects. It seems social virtues spring from a single font: selflessness.

Hold the applause. I don’t elect virtues. They are derivative of objective reasoning.

The Wheel of Misfortune

But wait.

There is one more automation.

“Like the beat, beat, beat of the tom-tom

When the jungle shadows fall

Like the tick, tick-tock of the stately clock

As it stands against the wall”

—Cole Porter, “Night and Day”

Destabilize.

Obsess.

Perfect.

Adapt.

Stabilize.

It is the Adaptor Loop. When something I observe contradicts my coherent semantics, I go bananas.

I destabilize.

I obsess over the anomaly.

I find the solution.

I perfect it.

I adapt myself to it.

And I settle in.

The adaptation has become my new normal.

Now that we have an explanatory model, let’s project it onto my three-year-old self.

I know one remarkable fact about myself at about three years old. My mother told me this story repeatedly.

“Mom, I am a changeling.”

Did I infer?

Wrong family.

Wrong people.

Wrong species.

No worries, Mom.

I belonged elsewhere.

I don’t remember this.

I am told it happened.

No clue what I meant.

Jiminy Cricket!

That is aggravating.

My best guess?

At three years old, I knew I was not a boy?

There are no memories. Nor semantic ash.

Boys and Girls

Now place that child in the 1950s. Boys and girls were not permitted wiggle room.

Boys lacked “sugar and spice and everything nice.”

Boys were tough.

Boys knew their worth.

Boys proved themselves.

Boys fought back.

Boys fought for what they wanted.

But my dinky self exhibited the complementary traits. Starting from selflessness, every virtue fell into place.

What species of man subordinates his own interests when another’s appear more dear? In the 1950s, virtues were coded female.

So what happens when a little boy exhibits virtues?

I don’t remember the conversations.

I cannot claim the language spoken. But the conflict between child and culture is inevitable.

Gary, stop that!

Gary, boys push back!

Gary, boys don’t do that.

Gary, that’s for girls.

Again.

And again.

On repeat.

Destabilize

Hello, world. “I am morally perfected.”

Gary, act like a boy.

Gary, don’t act like a girl.

Gary, are you a girl?

The existing model no longer converges.

Destabilize.

Something is wrong.

Obsess

What am I?

Where do I belong?

Why am I like this?

In the 1950s, there are two gender categories.

Boy.

Girl. ✅

At birth, after a cursory survey, the doctor categorized me as a “boy.” But the behavioral evidence keeps returning “girl.”

Run Constraint Convergence.

Perfect

There is an extraordinarily simple solution. Those bozos screwed up my classification.

I am a girl.

Suddenly, the constraints converge. The contradiction disappears.

Adapt.

Accept the new reality.

Stabilize.

I am a girl.

Done.

That is important.

I don’t have to spend the next seventy years continually deciding whether I am a girl. The problem has been solved. The system has stabilized.

“Girl” is now settled and part of reality.

Truth

Now semantic memory does what semantic memory does. The original evidence isn’t necessary anymore.

The corrections disappear.

The incidents disappear.

The derivation disappears.

What remains is the product:

I am a girl.

Truth.

Truth doesn’t carry a footnote explaining how it became true.

Paris is in France.

Drop something and it falls.

I am a girl.

Ask me why Paris is in France, and I can investigate its history. But I don’t require that history to know where Paris is.

Likewise, once “I am a girl” becomes semantic knowledge, the childhood evidence that produced it can disappear completely.

Isn’t that crazy? I have the rule, but I don’t know how it got there.

What Is a Girl?

It is crazy how the solution to one problem leads to another.

✅ I am a girl.

Fine.

What is a girl?

Hey, I am three years old. I haven’t the foggiest.

But I have a girl exemplar conveniently available to me.

Me.

I am a girl (see above).

Ergo:

A girl is someone like me.

A girl must be?

Selfless.

Harmless.

Gentle.

Sacrificing.

Forgiving.

Trusting.

Helpful.

Brainy.

Those aren’t traits I discovered by studying girls over years. Instead, I projected the gifts/curses I found in myself.

My People

Erroneously, girls are my people. Of course I want to be around them.

Except there is a peculiar problem.

I see girls.

They see me as a boy.

I can observe the bitches endlessly, but I alter the thing I am observing simply by being there.

I see:

Girl interacting with boy.

I don’t see:

Girl interacting with a girl.

So I cannot easily discover my mistake. I am standing outside the category trying to learn what happens inside it.

What Does a Girl Look Like?

But observation can answer another question extremely well.

I know what a girl feels like on the inside.

A preadolescent me.

But what does a girl look like on the outside?

So, I obsessed and perfected.

Girls have curves.

Wear pretty things.

Have dreamy hair.

Sweet voices.

Like horses.

A wiggle and a walk.

A giggle and a talk.

I learn.

I duplicate.

Semantic memory fills out the category.

This is important.

I need not first think:

I desire those characteristics.

The mechanism can be simpler.

I already know: I am a girl.

And I learn: Girls are like this.

Therefore, these are the habits appropriate to someone in my category. I smile. I understand.

Classification first.

Specification second.

And now there is another contradiction.

The Wrong Exemplar

There was another category error buried inside my proper category.

Girls weren’t actually like me.

They were human beings with memories and knowledge.

They could be selfish.

Competitive.

Demanding.

Willful.

Aggressive.

Cruel.

Generous.

Kind.

Loving.

Wonderful.

Awful.

They wanted things.

They fought for things.

They protected their interests.

Eventually, I learned that girls weren’t my people after all.

Not in the sense I had meant it.

I was just as strange among women as I had been among men.

But that discovery corrected:

This is what girls are like.

It did not necessarily correct:

I am a girl.

Why would it?

The derivation connecting those propositions was gone. Semantic memory had consumed it years earlier.

The evidence disappeared.

The truth remained.

What Are Little Girls Made Of?

There is an odd piece of corroborating history.

In 1966, when I was fourteen, Star Trek aired an episode called “What Are Little Girls Made Of?” I knew one scene remarkably well.

Near death, Dr. Roger Korby transferred his mind into an android. He insists that he remains himself. His knowledge is there. His intelligence is there. His abilities are there.

When challenged, his instinct is to demonstrate what he can do:

“I’m not a computer. Test me.”

Give me a problem.

Watch me solve it.

Then another android, Andrea, tells him that she loves him.

Korby tells her she cannot.

She isn’t human.

The irony is exquisite.

A machine who insists that his own internal experience establishes his humanity tells another machine that her internal experience cannot possibly be real.

I remembered that.

Of all the Star Trek I watched, I remembered that.

And around that period of my life, observing my own behavior and the reactions of people around me, I had developed a recurring explanation of my own.

Perhaps I was some kind of machine. A probe from an alien race. Not because I thought I had wires underneath my skin. A robot made from flesh and blood. A clever ruse to make me undetectable.

But still I behaved like a robot.

Observing and recording human behavior while failing to operate quite like them. I expected they would retrieve my data someday. And then dispose of me, my mission done.

At the time, I was clueless.

I didn’t have SDAM.

I didn’t have ASD.

I didn’t have aphantasia.

I didn’t have semantic architecture.

I didn’t have any of the vocabulary.

For most of my life, I was depressed and haunted by intrusive voices. I was on fire with curiosity. I was obsessed with learning and mastering skills. I observed, dissected, and catalogued every human behavior.

Why not an alien probe?