Madness in My Method

By Jessica Lake

I have SDAM.

I don’t remember my life—

I know it.

Big diff, you might say.

I have repeated most of the stories that follow in my mind for many decades. Apparently, these were things my younger selves decided were important.

That should sound strange to you. You see, I am a stranger to those others who came before me. I have no access to their inner state.

What were they thinking?

What were they feeling?

What didn’t they know?

What were their hopes?

Quoth the Raven, “Nevermore.”

Oddly, these stories hurt me anew on each recall. Not yesterday’s hurt. Today’s.

Why keep repeating something that hurts?

I have few recollections. Most of them bad. Perhaps it is that misfortune is an excellent teacher.

What follows is how I understand the evidence now. The dialogue is reconstructed. Where I supply thoughts, feelings, or motives, they are inferences, not inner experiences I can relive.

Here are a few.

Do You Really Need to Be Paid?

When I was in my twenties, I worked for my dad. Why? Because he asked.

His pipsqueak startup was sputtering. Sometimes payday would roll around and he would say:

“Do you really need to be paid this week?”

Parse that question.

Not: “I can’t pay you this week.”

Not: “Can I owe you the money?”

Do you really need to be paid?

As though recompense for a full week’s labor was negotiable. As though whether he owed me the money was not the point. It depended upon whether I needed it.

And I would say:

“Shucks, no. I’m fine.”

No?

No, he didn’t pay me later.

Why would he?

Didn’t I already agree I didn’t need it?

No worries.

Why would I need my paycheck?

I gave most of it to my mother.

She spent it on my little brothers.

Seems my dad hadn’t paid her either.

Michael’s Houses

My little brother Michael, just married, wanted to buy his first home.

He asked. I gave.

Five thousand dollars.

Not much.

Later, he sold that house.

Did he pay me back? No.

Instead, he asked me to help him buy a bigger house.

Of course he did.

Why wouldn’t he?

I had taught him how Jessica works. If someone asked—I gave.

“Pay me back when you can.”

I don’t think I expected Michael to.

There is something sweet about that.

They were gifts.

Real gifts.

As I understand it now, I wasn’t seeking gratitude.

I wasn’t keeping a ledger.

I wasn’t even thinking of myself as generous.

They needed something.

I had it.

So, I gave it.

What could be more noble than that?

The Stone House

Years later, Nikki and I were married.

We had a ranch house. We were building a life. My dad had stopped paying the mortgage on the Stone House. It went into foreclosure and then to auction.

The thought I give myself now is:

Oh my God! Other than that house, they have nothing.

So I went to the auction and bought it. As it was a second property, I took out a costly investment loan.

The plan was simple.

Flip the house.

Keep what it cost me.

The rest goes to my parents.

Not much. But something.

Nikki agreed.

We received an offer.

I seem to have thought:

This is the first offer. Maybe we should wait and see what else comes along.

Four years later, no more offers.

Eventually, the police went through the abandoned house. They left a notice, which amounted to:

“Secure and clean up this dump, or else.”

It did look like a dumpster.

My father had left shotgun-shell supplies and casings everywhere. The roof leaked, so everything upstairs was now downstairs. The junk sat in sad and sagging paper boxes.

Kids must have rifled through the boxes. They’d scattered stuff helter-skelter.

I asked my brothers to help me clean.

“Love to—can’t.”

I rented a long dumpster.

And every weekend that long, hot summer, I spent cleaning the Stone House. This while still commuting to New York City and working long hours during the week.

I went through the trash with a fine-tooth comb. Who knew what heirlooms I might find?

Surprisingly, none.

Anomaly.

Years later, I learned that my brothers had already gone through the house. As I understand it, they hadn’t worked together. They had competed. They had torn the place apart and taken everything of value.

Do you think that’s why they didn’t help me?

And there I was, in the summer heat, cleaning up the mess they had made.

I was a fool.

And perhaps I relished it.

I did find things that might have value as keepsakes.

“Maybe someone would like this?”

And I made little piles of things.

A pair of bell-bottoms.

Boy Scout patches.

Broken toys.

Outdated cassette tapes.

Whatever remained of our lives in that house.

Let us see. I had bought the house and its contents. Yet my attention still went to whether a sibling might want something.

And there was my wife Nikki.

I was working long hours in New York City during the week and spending my weekends cleaning the house.

What was my Nikki doing?

What was she thinking and feeling?

Shouldn’t she come first?

Where were my brothers?

Where was my sister?

Didn’t anybody care?

Why was it always me?

Eventually, we sold the house for a pittance. I lost about forty thousand dollars.

I can’t recall a thank-you. Not even from my parents.

I had fucked up. Again. Perhaps that kind of selfishness helped push us toward divorce.

Fooled you!

Remember, I have no episodic memory. That is a semantic reconstruction. Using the little I know, it is my best guess of what might have happened. I haven’t the slightest idea what was going on inside that sad sack of a man those decades ago.

Twenty-Four Thousand Dollars

I did it again with my second wife, Taryn.

My brother in Spain sent me a letter saying he was having trouble paying his mortgage. So I sent him a thousand dollars a month.

For two years.

My wife screamed at me:

“That’s our money, not your money.”

And I kept saying:

“Can’t you see? It’s my brother. He needs it.”

At twenty-four thousand dollars, I stopped.

About ten years later, I spoke to that brother by phone. He said it had never happened. There was no money.

“Why would you lie like that?”

“But—I can show you,” I said. “I have the wire transfers.”

“Don’t bother. I’m sure they are fraudulent. You are a monster. I never want to speak to you again.”

We have never spoken since.

Trust

There were red flags with my second wife:

She was in bankruptcy.

She cried all the time.

She hated her job.

She was broke.

But I understood. Or thought I did.

For too long, as I saw it, she had loved a man who would not grow up. The divorce was hard. She came out in debt. She seemed lost and frustrated.

It’s easy to lose your way.

After we married, she asked if she might handle our finances.

Sure.

There were more red flags.

I saw them.

But what was I supposed to do?

Take away the credit card I gave her?

How can you have a marriage without trust?

Somehow, she maxed my credit card to thirty-five thousand dollars. Something like a grand a month in interest. She did it three times. A hundred and five thousand dollars.

She insisted she had done nothing wrong.

It was my fault.

I didn’t make enough.

Emily’s care was expensive.

Perhaps the twenty-four thousand dollars I sent my brother helped her justify it. Only, I never took any money for myself.

She did.

I once wrote this poem about her:

My wife has a wound that is unseen.

Slight at the first, each day since she has picked it raw.

Until now it vexes her without cease.

It is her treasure.

For the inflictor of such an injury is beyond succor.

It is the indulgence of her every sin—

No desire forbidden—

Nor betrayal.

She smiles.

She is free.

Would that I had not wounded her so.

Look at the poem’s end. In the logic I was describing, she could do anything. And it would always be my fault.

Our Parents

Eventually, my parents could no longer care for themselves.

A bit later, my brother had pituitary cancer.

I decided to live with my parents and take care of them.

When John could no longer function, I took care of him too.

The word “decided” seems wrong. It was my moral duty.

This happened at an interesting time financially.

After fourteen wasted years at the bank, they laid me off.

My severance was a full year’s salary.

I had the time.

I had money.

I spent them both caregiving.

I bought food.

I paid my expenses.

I paid for what we needed.

My sister paid the mortgage and other bills. She made sure she was reimbursed from the estate.

I was trapped in the house. Everything had to be delivered.

I fed them.

Washed them.

Changed their diapers.

Took my parents to doctors.

Took John to chemo.

My father’s was, comparatively, an easy death.

He fell asleep.

He went to hospice.

That’s when my brothers and sister came.

At the end.

Once.

Days later, his heart gave out.

That’s it.

At home, I dealt with my mother’s dementia.

I exercised in the living room.

Mom would scream at me.

She wouldn’t stop.

Until I stopped.

Toward the end, I slept beside her, so I could be right there.

When she died, I held her.

John’s death was rough.

Fluid accumulated in his abdomen until his belly became distended.

They put in a drain.

Every day, I drained the fluid and disposed of it.

Hospice nurses came. I did have help. They would wash him and do things. Half an hour here and there.

The rest was on me.

I put John’s hospital bed downstairs next to the couch where I slept.

If he needed me, I was there.

He was receiving morphine and, as I describe it now, starving for a month.

That’s when my brothers, sister, and family came.

At the end.

Once.

For roughly three years, including John’s care, I gave myself to caring for the three who knew me most.

Apart from those final visits, there was one exception to the absence of visitors.

My cousin, more angel than kin.

She visited my parents and always brought them food they loved.

I know that.

She was kind to them.

But no child or grandchild came to take over for a day.

Nobody said:

Go somewhere. I’ve got them.

If I wanted to leave, I had to pay someone to stay with them.

Sixty dollars an hour.

And where did I go?

I went to watch my daughter perform.

I had promised her I would always be there.

Even my escape was a promise.

Free

At some point, I said something to Aleta.

“Most caregivers would be paid a lot of money to do what I did.”

She looked at me as though I had said something ridiculous.

“What are you talking about? You got to live there for free.”

Free.

That’s funny.

It wasn’t only Aleta. Every sibling I spoke to about the care gave me essentially the same answer.

What are you complaining about? You got to live there for free.

I had entered the house with a year’s severance.

My sister paid the mortgage and other bills. She made sure those payments were reimbursed from the estate.

She understood reimbursement.

I think she even paid herself for her time.

Why wouldn’t she?

Other than care, she handled the other affairs. She was entitled to reimbursement.

Perfectly reasonable.

For me?

Perfectly unreasonable.

Later, I tried putting a price on what “free” had meant.

For roughly two and a half years, I lived with my parents and provided their daily care. For about eighteen months, I cared for both of them. For another year, I cared for my mother alone.

I cooked. Helped them bathe, dress, and use the toilet. Managed meals, medication reminders, errands, and transportation. I was there overnight. If something happened, I was the person who responded.

For this estimate, I allowed three hundred dollars a day for one person’s care and another hundred and fifty for the second. On that basis, the work came to approximately three hundred and fifty-six thousand dollars.

But I lived there for free.

Fine. Give the housing its full credit. At two thousand dollars a month for thirty months, that was sixty thousand dollars. Deduct it.

Then add what I paid for groceries, diapers, wipes, and other necessities. I estimated those expenses at five hundred dollars a month—another fifteen thousand dollars.

After crediting the housing and including those expenses, my estimated unpaid contribution was still about three hundred and eleven thousand dollars.

That did not include the sixty-dollar-an-hour sitter I paid when I needed to leave. It did not put a price on interrupted work, exhaustion, or the rest of my life. And it did not include the care I gave John.

This was an estimate of the work’s replacement cost and my expenses, not a bill I had presented to anyone.

But apparently the room was compensation.

Free.

The implication I hear now is that I had nothing to give up. I got to exist there. What more could I want?

It’s not like I was doing anything.

But those years were mine, even if I had not decided what to do with them.

And there was something I did give up. I felt I had only a few good years left to explore intimacy and be sexually active as a woman. Caregiving consumed much of that opportunity.

A room could not give those years back.

But here is the strange part.

I think I would have been disappointed if someone had helped me.

It was my sacrifice.

You can’t take that from me.

I kept everything together.

I was the good daughter.

The Dog

There is a prequel to “living there for free.”

It took place before I moved in with my parents.

My ex-wife and daughter had an apartment.

I had an apartment close by.

My ex-wife moved in with her boyfriend.

I hoped only the best for them. Perhaps he forgot he had Alzheimer’s?

I let my apartment go.

I moved in with my daughter.

Somehow, I started paying the rent.

Soon, our daughter moved in with her mom.

Kids.

Then I went to live with my parents. We could let the empty apartment go.

Did I mention my daughter’s two cats and dog?

My ex-wife took the cats.

The boyfriend was now a child-friend.

The dog was very old, sick, and crapped and pissed everywhere.

Reasonably, I suggested to my ex-wife:

“Why don’t you put the dog to sleep?”

“Our daughter would never allow that. She would be heartbroken.”

The dog needed a natural death.

The dog preferred to die at home.

Instead of working, my ex-wife cared for her boyfriend. Where were his grown-up kids? There was no way she could pay the rent.

No sacrifice is too great for my daughter.

“Besides,” she said, “you’ll be living with your parents for free.”

So, for eight months, I paid rent for a dying dog.

My ex-wife was very good at that.

In the end, they put the dog to sleep. But only because the dog was suffering too much.

Lunch

John liked an expensive restaurant.

Toward the end, he always wanted to go there for lunch.

He said he had no money.

So I paid.

He would order a lot of things.

Then he couldn’t eat them.

They would go in the trash.

Once or twice, I said:

“John, why don’t you order the stuff one dish at a time? Then, if you don’t feel like eating anymore, you can stop.”

That’s all.

Now I look back and think:

How could you do that to him?

He’s dying of cancer and you won’t let him enjoy his meal?

Think about that.

I was taking him to the restaurant.

I was paying for the meal.

I was caring for him while he was dying.

I was taking him to chemotherapy.

I was sleeping on the couch beside his hospital bed.

I was draining the fluid from his abdomen every day.

And what survives as the moral failure?

I asked him to order one dish at a time.

Apparently, nothing acquits Jessica.

But that convicts her.

The Lawyer

Toward the end, John was very sick.

He was taking codeine for the pain.

One day, my sister Aleta came in with a man.

He turned out to be a lawyer.

She had John sign a will leaving everything to her.

I didn’t say a word.

Why would I?

John had already told me that he wanted everything to go to Aleta.

That was his wish.

It was his property.

His decision.

The circumstances looked questionable to me.

But I had John’s own statement of what he wanted.

So I didn’t interfere.

Did I get anything?

No.

Why would I get anything?

The Jeep

John had a Jeep.

I liked it.

After he died, while the estate was still in probate, I told Aleta I wanted to buy it.

“I’ll give you five thousand dollars for it.”

She said no.

She had promised to give it to her daughter.

That was that.

I had taken care of John while he was dying.

I drove him to chemotherapy.

I slept on the couch beside his hospital bed.

I drained the fluid from his abdomen every day.

I fed him.

I paid for his lunches.

I stayed with him while he died.

And when there was something of his that I wanted, I didn’t ask for it.

I offered to buy it.

Five thousand dollars.

Aleta had promised to give it to her daughter.

So she did.

John’s Things

After John died, I took over his apartment.

It was a beautiful apartment.

All his possessions were there.

Among them were things he had taken from the Stone House.

As I understood their ownership, those things weren’t John’s alone.

They belonged to the family.

I explained that to Aleta.

“They belong to all of us. Not to you.”

I believed I had a claim.

Then I thought about it.

Michael was dead.

John was dead.

My parents were dead.

Eddie was in Florida.

Jeffery was in Spain.

My brothers were distant and weren’t particularly interested in me, as far as I could tell.

What was I going to do with this stuff?

I was trying to own less, not more.

So I relinquished my claim.

I gave it to her.

Aleta said she would clean out John’s apartment.

She came over.

She took everything of value.

She never came back.

His clothes.

His ordinary possessions.

Everything that wasn’t worth taking.

More than two years later, it’s still upstairs.

Apparently, the valuables were Aleta’s.

The garbage was John’s.

And John was mine.

Two Shares

I was co-executor of my mother’s estate with Aleta.

She took control.

She almost never spoke to me except to give me things to sign.

My mother’s will said that her estate was to be distributed equally among her surviving children.

My mother died before John.

That mattered.

As I understood it, John therefore inherited his share when Mom died.

Then John died.

His will left everything to Aleta.

I was the one who noticed what that meant.

I told her:

“You know you’re entitled to John’s share.”

She seemed not to have seen it.

She thought about it.

Then she seemed to understand.

As we understood the estates, she was entitled to two shares.

Her own.

And John’s.

Then I said:

“Of course, that wasn’t Mom’s wish. You know she wanted everything divided equally.”

She nodded.

I took that to mean she understood that too.

She kept both shares.

And that was the end of my intervention.

Why?

Because, as I understood it, the money belonged to her.

Period.

Once it was hers, the decision was hers.

I could counsel her.

I could tell her what I understood Mom to have wanted.

I could make sure she heard it.

But I couldn’t make the moral decision for her.

See?

I am very good at finding moral reasons why Jessica deserves nothing.

No Need to Ask

My sister was newly married. She made it clear money was tight. So I put Aleta on my credit card.

Why?

So if she needed something, she could buy it.

She wouldn’t have to ask.

That seems to have been my idea of kindness.

Think about how complete that is.

I didn’t merely give.

I arranged it so she would not have to face the embarrassment of asking.

If someone I loved needed something and I had the ability to provide it, why should she have to come to me and justify herself?

Just buy it.

I saw red flags in my life.

That is important.

I wasn’t simply oblivious.

Sometimes I seem to have known perfectly well that something could go wrong.

I answered the red flags with virtues.

Suspicion?

Trust.

Someone needs something?

Generosity.

Someone else’s property?

Respect their ownership.

Someone else’s decision?

Respect their autonomy.

Someone else’s suffering?

Help.

My own claim?

Why?

Almost a Compliment

There was something else.

Years later, my sister told me that I made people angry.

I hadn’t known.

She said it almost as though it were simply a fact.

She didn’t tell me why.

Perhaps there was something abrasive about me.

Perhaps it was autism.

Perhaps I could seem cold or cruel without realizing it.

I don’t know.

These are guesses.

I infer my life.

What else can I do?

Perhaps my family had grievances against me that I couldn’t see.

Perhaps those grievances gave them permission, in their own minds.

Perhaps that is why people could take so much from me and seem to feel so little gratitude.

I cannot know. But even if I had been unkind, I don’t think that would make what they did deserved.

Then there is Michael.

I had become a good cook.

One day, I made a beautiful barbecue dinner.

Michael was eating something.

He started to say how delicious it was.

Then he stopped.

“Did you make that?”

“Yes.”

“That was close. I almost gave you a compliment.”

It was a joke.

He had liked the food.

The compliment had already begun.

Then he discovered that I had made it.

And withdrew it.

You would think my generosity might have purchased a little forgiveness.

Apparently not.

Or perhaps that’s me doing it again.

Perhaps I am searching for something I did that explains why they treated me the way they did.

Perhaps I need Jessica to be the cause.

I don’t know.

Almost everything I know about the person I was has to be inferred from the evidence she left behind.

Including this.

The Morally Perfected Woman

There is an old sentiment:

To forgive is noble; to forget is saintly.

I used to joke that I was a saint.

I forgot everything.

I didn’t hold grudges.

I didn’t demand repayment.

I didn’t need thanks.

I didn’t keep score.

I gave without expecting anything back.

That is the pattern I see now.

That matters.

I don’t want to explain the goodness away.

The gifts were genuine gifts.

I see no reason to assume I was secretly buying love.

Or accumulating moral credit.

Or waiting for everyone to tell me what a wonderful person I was.

If anything, gratitude seems to have made me uncomfortable.

I don’t think I wanted repayment.

I don’t think I even wanted help.

A gift that expects repayment isn’t a gift.

A sacrifice that earns compensation isn’t quite a sacrifice.

I was the one who gave.

That was my role.

What could be more virtuous?

The Role

I was the one who kept everything together.

I believed in my father.

I supported him.

I was his cheerleader.

I helped my mother get to college so she could become a nurse.

I helped my brothers.

I paid.

I rescued the Stone House.

I cared for the dying.

I sacrificed so that the family remained whole.

The Person Underneath

But that makes it sound too peaceful.

It wasn’t.

The person I reconstruct underneath all of this is tortured, trying desperately to figure out why everyone else seemed happy and he seemed empty.

He watched people.

Studied them.

Learned the rules.

Tried relationships.

Marriage.

Family.

Work.

Achievement.

Service.

He seems to have tried to become like everyone else.

As I understand it now, he knew there was something missing.

He didn’t know what.

He didn’t know who he was.

But perhaps that meant he could be anybody.

And he wanted to be a woman.

Even that, he wouldn’t permit himself.

Think about that.

The person who would give almost anything to anyone couldn’t give himself that.

Eventually, he did.

And Jessica appeared.

Collapse

Then my mother died.

My father died.

John died.

And I collapsed completely.

The hospice people said it was grief.

So I went to therapy.

But I think I had lost more than people.

I had lost my purpose.

There was no one left who needed me enough to tell me what to do.

No one to give me permission.

I seem to have had no strong desires of my own.

I had spent my life giving myself away.

And suddenly there was nobody left to give myself to.

I was without purpose.

As I understand it now, I went into therapy hoping for two things.

I wanted to understand my distress.

Surely something had happened to me.

Surely there was a reason I was like this.

And I wanted my memories back.

I thought they were in there somewhere.

Suppressed.

Locked away.

Damaged.

Something.

Find the cause.

Recover the memories.

Fix me.

That was the explanation I was searching for, not something I had established.

But underneath those two things, I think, was the real hope.

I wanted my therapist to teach me how to become like everyone else.

I wanted to sit on a couch with friends and laugh and simply feel good being there with them.

I wanted someone I loved to leave and for me to miss them.

I wanted to think about someone who wasn’t there and feel warm because I loved them.

I wanted to look backward and feel:

That was me.

That happened to me.

I was happy then.

I wanted to know what I wanted.

Not what made sense.

Not what somebody else needed.

Not what the constraints permitted.

What I wanted.

And I wanted wanting it to be enough.

I wanted to give myself permission.

I wanted to belong.

I didn’t want to spend the rest of my life standing outside, looking in, enjoying life vicariously through everyone else’s joys and sorrows.

That is what I now understand myself to have gone into therapy hoping to find