Two With One Stone

By Jessica Lake


Other people are entitled to happiness. For me, there’s paperwork. First become worthy. Then we’ll discuss the application. Meanwhile, I’ve been remarkably inventive about providing good things for everyone else. How convenient. SDAM has misplaced much of the original correspondence, but the restrictions remain in force. What if giving became a way to enjoy what I couldn’t permit myself to receive? An ingenious arrangement. I’d like to speak to whoever approved

I stand at the intersection of neurodivergence, gender dysphoria, severe childhood duress, and a particular temperament.

For most of my life, neither I nor the people around me possessed the language to explain what that combination produced. It took two years of therapy, research, and relentless analysis before the pieces began to fit together.

The result is a story that is complex, extreme, and profoundly sad.

To others, I might have appeared to be an intellectual and athletic polymath: an engineer who solved difficult technical problems, a martial artist, dancer, singer, writer, and lifelong student of almost anything that interested me. I seemed disciplined, capable, endlessly curious, and adaptable.

Inside, however, I felt defective, splintered, and perpetually clueless. I was a man struggling to understand who I was. A man in extremis. Adrift in a tempest of intrusive thoughts—worthlessness, inadequacy, suicide.

Who was I? Why was I so different? Why was I so broken?

The outward appearance and inward experience could not have been farther apart.

The good news: I finally found an explanation that made sense to me.

The bad news: it took seventy-four years.

My rudest awakening was discovering how much I had assumed about the experience I shared with other people. I had spent a lifetime believing that their machinery worked much as mine did.

This paper examines two patterns through my current architectural model: the Pejorative Self and the Surrogate Loop.

One generated a verdict against me. The other found a way to meet needs within the restrictions that remained.

Pejorative Self

The following is a constructed illustration, set around a surviving fragment from first grade. The classroom scenes and dialogue give the problem a shape; they are not a continuous recollection.

We set our story in 1958, Norwalk, Connecticut. It begins with little Oliver Twist starting first grade. The boy is perhaps a bit too small and skinny.

The teacher begins class. Oliver speaks out of turn.

Not a problem. Lots of boys get overexcited.

“Oliver, if you need to speak, raise your hand. Then I will call on you.”

“Yes, ma’am,” comes the tidy little reply.

The next day, he blurts out another answer.

The teacher smiles patiently.

“Remember, Oliver. Raise your hand first.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

Weeks pass. The interruptions mount.

The teacher changes his seat. She praises him when he remembers. She gently redirects him when he forgets. She speaks with his parents. She tries encouragement. She tries consequences.

Nothing seems to make a difference.

Three months later, the teacher sits with a cigarette in the faculty lounge.

“I just can’t get through to this boy. The kid never stops talking. Half of what he says seems to come from another conversation. But other than that, he’s a sweet kid. I don’t know what else to try.”

At home, little Oliver labors to be good.

Bump.

“Just shut up.”

Bump.

“Just shut up.”

Bump.

In the morning, there is a circular indentation in the wall. Just about the size of a little boy’s forehead.

It is a beautiful June day. The school year has come to an end. The teacher gathers the last of her things.

“Why couldn’t I reach him? I tried everything I know. Rewards. Patience. Gentle reminders. Consequences. Nothing changed. He’s as disruptive today as he was the day we met. Maybe he’ll mature over the summer. Maybe this is simply who he is.”

Leaving work for a joyful summer, she smiles.

“Thankfully, next year, he will be somebody else’s problem.”

The End

The fragment beneath this illustration has been with me always. I remember standing at my grandmother’s house, repeatedly striking my head against a wall while saying:

“Why can’t you just shut up?”

What follows is my current explanation of how that fragment fits with the rules and verdicts that survived. I have no episodic history through which I can watch the process unfold.

For years, I assumed my pejorative self-image came from the way other people treated me.

That treatment certainly mattered. There was emotional and physical abuse, public shaming, and social isolation. I encountered judgments that I was smart but lazy, capable but unwilling, bright but rebellious.

But I no longer need an explanation in which I borrowed someone else’s verdict or methods.

I could generate the verdict myself.

I was steeped in the idea of agency. If I knew what was wrong, understood the correction, and sincerely intended to change, then I should be able to change.

A person makes a mistake. He learns from it. Then he does better.

But I didn’t.

I knew I had made a mistake. I knew what I was supposed to do instead. I sincerely intended to do it differently next time.

Then I did the same thing again.

I tried. I failed. I promised myself I would do better. I failed again.

After the hundredth time, what conclusion remained?

If you cannot learn, Jessica, you deserve what you get.

Knowing the rule was not enough to change the behavior. But I did not have an architectural explanation for that distinction. I assumed the failure belonged to the person in charge.

Me.

What do you call a person who doesn’t learn from mistakes?

Broken.

Nobody had to teach me that conclusion. I could reach it myself.

The problem was no longer something I did. The problem was what I was.

I was both the accused and the judge.

The judgments around me reinforced that conclusion. Their disappointment agreed with mine. Their punishments appeared consistent with what I already believed about myself.

The waves reinforced one another.

A rogue wave.

My current model places the origin of the Pejorative Self in that unresolved contradiction: I assumed I possessed the power to correct myself, yet repeated effort failed to produce the correction.

Every failure became evidence against me.

The resulting verdict did not require an antagonist to install it. Semantic reasoning could preserve the failures, apply the same premise, and return the same answer.

You knew. You tried. You failed again.

What is wrong with you?

Eventually, the verdict became a prohibition:

Nothing good for you until you can get some control over yourself.

Good things would have to wait until I had learned to behave.

I denied myself pleasure. I refused to burden other people. I learned to live with less than I required. I held myself to standards I would never have imposed upon another human being.

Every failure demanded another restriction.

Nothing good for you. Not yet. First learn to behave.

But the correction never arrived.

The sentence never reached its end.

Then the architecture did what it did so well.

It adapted.

I learned to live without the things I had prohibited. I stopped looking for good things for myself.

That created another terrible consistency. A life in which I repeatedly failed to protect or provide for myself looked like further evidence that I did not value myself.

The conclusion and the conduct reinforced one another.

I was worthless.

This is an inference from the surviving artifacts: the prohibitions, the self-punishment, the repeated attempts to change, and the life that followed. It is not a recovered sequence of childhood thoughts.

The tragedy is that an architecture capable of learning so much could keep returning a verdict against its own conscious inhabitant.

Surrogate Loop

The prohibition created another problem.

Nothing good for you until you learn to behave.

But natural needs did not disappear.

I was still a social creature. Love, affection, belonging, acceptance, pleasure, and beauty still mattered. Those needs required satisfaction even without a personally chosen life direction.

Duress did not create my underlying architecture. It supplied constraints.

Within my current model, many duress rules functioned protectively:

Don’t depend. Don’t ask. Don’t receive. Stay in control. Survive.

Never reveal vulnerability, because it can be used against you.

“Stay in control” was a rule. It did not establish that I possessed agentic control over my life. It prohibited arrangements in which another person could use my dependence or vulnerability against me.

The protective function matters. These rules were solutions to duress, even when their later consequences were costly.

Constraints do not necessarily eliminate a need. They can eliminate the admissible paths to satisfying it.

Close connection could expose vulnerability. Dependence could place me in another person’s hands. Receiving could require something from someone whose response I could not determine.

Alongside those restrictions stood another:

Nothing good for you. Not until you have learned to behave.

The architecture had a problem.

The needs remained. Direct routes were prohibited.

It needed another route.

A surrogate.

Rather than receive fulfillment directly, I could generate it for someone else and experience it through them.

I could provide love instead of asking for it. I could create happiness instead of seeking it for myself. I could give pleasure instead of requiring another person to give it to me.

Through empathy, the surrogate’s fulfillment became available vicariously.

The flow began with me and returned to me through that experience.

I did not have to ask. I did not have to depend upon reciprocation. I did not have to claim the good thing directly for myself.

The surrogate occupied the recipient’s place.

I generated the care, pleasure, or fulfillment. Through the surrogate, I could experience something of what I had generated.

Within the logic of the loop, I remained on the permitted side of the transaction.

Giving.

The loop did not require another person to return the same gift. Its protection lay in that independence. This does not mean another person could never hurt me. It means their reciprocation was not required for this route to fulfillment to operate.

That is the solution I now see.

The Pejorative Self generated a verdict and a prohibition against good things for me.

The Surrogate Loop found an admissible way to meet needs without overturning that prohibition.

The second was an ingenious adaptation to the first. It need not have been a conscious strategy. The architecture could produce the arrangement without an agent deciding that this was the life she wanted.

I had natural needs to meet.

The machinery found a way.

That distinction changes how I understand the result. I do not need to posit a desired life hidden beneath the arrangement, waiting to be recovered.

What I can identify are needs, constraints, and a recurring solution.

Nor does “worked” mean that the solution was good for me across a lifetime.

It means that needs received some satisfaction while the prohibitions remained intact.

A terrible solution can work.

This one worked for seventy years.

The architecture was doing the best it could with the wrong tools: resolving how to function within constraints without supplying the agentic direction I believe was missing.

This model appears to connect more of my life than I first imagined: my relationships, my sexuality, the structure of my fantasies, the way I masturbated, and how I continued to function.

Whether it ultimately explains those observations remains open. I cannot replay the process and watch it happen.

I have its surviving rules, its apparent regularities, and the evidence of my life.

But for the first time in seventy-four years, I have an explanation that accounts for those pieces as a system.

The boy was trying to become good. He never stopped trying.

When repeated correction failed, the verdict turned against him.

When good things were prohibited, he adapted to their absence.

And when natural needs still required an answer—

the machinery found someone else to give the good things to.